Appraisal Came in Low? What to Do Next

You’ve found your dream home, made an offer, and everything seems to be going smoothly—until the appraisal comes back lower than the purchase price. 😱

Now what?

A low value can feel like a deal breaker, but it doesn’t have to be. Whether you’re using a conventional, FHA, or VA loan, there are strategic ways to navigate this challenge and still move forward with your home purchase.

In this guide, we’ll walk you through what a low appraisal means, how it impacts your mortgage, and the steps you can take depending on your loan type.

---

Why Is a Low Appraisal a Problem?

Your lender bases the mortgage amount on the appraised value of the home—not the purchase price.

📌 Example:

• Purchase Price: $400,000

• Appraised Value: $380,000

• Mortgage is based on: $380,000

This creates a $20,000 gap, which you, the buyer, must bridge by either negotiating with the seller, increasing your down payment, or exploring other options.

---

How to Handle a Low Appraisal: By Loan Type

🔹 Conventional Loan (Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac)

Conventional loans offer some flexibility—but you cannot simply order a new appraisal because the value came in low.

What You Can Do:

• ✅ Reconsideration of Value (ROV): Submit additional comparable sales (“comps”) that support a higher value.

• ✅ Correct Errors: If the appraisal has missing info, outdated comps, or market data errors, request corrections.

• ✅ Market Trend Adjustments: If prices in the area are rising, appraisers may adjust the value accordingly.

📝 A second appraisal is only allowed if the first one contains material errors or the appraiser is uncooperative.

---

🔸 FHA Loan

FHA loans are a bit stricter when it comes to appraisals—and the appraisal sticks with the property for 180 days (6 months).

Key Points:

• ❌ You can’t order a second appraisal unless the first one has major issues.

• 📎 A low FHA appraisal affects any FHA buyer for the next 6 months—even if they’re not the original buyer.

• ✅ ROV is still an option, but you’ll need strong comps and data to support a higher value.

🧠 Sellers should know: if a deal falls through due to a low FHA appraisal, it could impact future sales.

---

🔹 VA Loan (Veterans Affairs)

VA loans offer the most flexibility and include unique features like the Tidewater Initiative.

Here’s how it works:

• 🌀 Tidewater Process: The appraiser notifies the lender when value may come in low. The lender then has 48 hours to submit additional comps.

• 📤 ROV Process: If the final appraisal still comes in low, the buyer can submit a written request (with comps) to the VA Regional Loan Center.

• 📅 The VA has 5 business days to issue a decision.

✅ The Tidewater process gives buyers a chance to resolve the value issue before the appraisal is finalized.

---

Additional Solutions If the Appraisal Comes in Low

If reconsideration or comps don’t work, don’t panic. Here are some alternative strategies to consider:

💬 1. Negotiate With the Seller

• Ask the seller to reduce the purchase price to match the appraised value.

• Many sellers will agree, especially if they don’t want to start over with a new buyer.

💰 2. Increase Your Down Payment

• Cover the appraisal gap with additional cash.

• Best option if you’re financially able and want to stick with the current deal.

🗂 3. Submit Better Comparable Sales

• If you believe the appraiser used poor or outdated comps, work with your agent and lender to submit stronger ones.

🔁 4. Switch Loan Programs

• Consider moving from FHA to a conventional loan if it offers more flexibility.

• This can be especially useful in hot markets where appraisals often lag behind actual sale prices.

---

Proactive Tips for Buyers

Don’t wait for appraisal issues to pop up. Here’s how to stay ahead:

🛡 Always Have an Appraisal Gap Strategy

Especially in competitive markets, prepare in advance:

• Consider including appraisal gap coverage in your offer.

• Talk to your lender about backup financing options.

🧾 Review the Appraisal Report Carefully

• Look for inconsistencies or errors.

• Check if the comps are outdated or from a different neighborhood.

📞 Talk to Your Lender Immediately

• Time is critical.

• They’ll guide you on whether you can request a ROV and how to do it properly.

---

Final Thoughts: Don’t Let a Low Appraisal Derail Your Dream Home

A low appraisal might feel like a roadblock—but it’s more like a detour. With the right approach, solid communication with your lender, and strong negotiation tactics, you can keep your home purchase on track.

👉 Need help navigating a low appraisal situation?
Schedule a call with me today, and let’s go over your options together. I’ll help you chart the best path forward and protect your investment.